My union journey began with personal engagement...

The Friedrichs case this week has me thinking a lot about the importance of personal relationships and how those can bear fruit in ways we can't imagine. Very much like our students. We sometimes don't know who we are impacting and why, but we do the work, we plant the seed and it will germinate at some point. We do that as teachers because we have faith in that.

It's the same thing as a union member. For me it was Rene Flores, who with a conversation changed me from agency fee payer to site rep and unknowingly put me on this path of leadership and advocacy. That's why it's so important for our reps, and our regular rank and file members to talk to new teachers in the profession and let them know the importance of being a union member.

Unions have proven to be agents of change, we need to recognize that that is our role, no matter how the Supreme Court rules. 

The following piece appeared in the CTA magazine California Educator, in December of 2015, I talk about my journey from fee payer to activist . . . 

Unions Mater

Part 1:  What is a Union?

You’d think by the rhetoric from the right that Labor Unions dominate the landscape as they ravage and bring ruin to the nation’s economy. Here is the fact: according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in 2014 “the percent of wage and salary workers who were members of unions—was 11.1 percent, down 0.2 percentage point from 2013” The truth is that unionized workers are at their lowest point since 1912. If it’s labor unions destroying the American Economy, it must be pretty weak for 11% of the workforce to be doing so much damage. Blaming the unions is just another one of those myths that the right has concocted to further weaken unions. I’m always surprised why the question isn’t “How can I get what you guys have?” 

What is a labor union?

labor union: n. an organization of workers formed for the purpose of advancing its members' interests in respect to wages, benefits, and working conditions. (Merriam-Webster)

The piece that isn’t captured by the definition is the impact that labor unions have on non-unionized labor. In other words, the fight of unionized labor is a fight for improving the middle class. When the Sweetwater Education Association was fighting for the School District to honor it’s commitment to our health benefits I would occasionally hear from non-unionized workers say “why do you deserve health benefits? You should be grateful you get what you get!” With the implementation of Obamacare, we have yet another example of an idea that grew out of what labor unions do for their members into the mainstream. Labor unions have worked hard to develop the American Dream and now are attempting to protect it. 

Some historic union victories that have improved the lives of all Americans include:

  • Collective Bargaining
  • The Weekend
  • Child Labor Laws
  • Family Medical Leave Act
  • Paid Leave
  • Minimum Wage
  • Overtime Pay
  • Work Injury Protection
  • Secure Retirement

Many of these victories came during the “Progressive Era” of the late and early 1900s. Other victories came during the 1930s, most notably the National Labor Relations Act or Wagner Act.

Protecting the Promise of Public Education

Furthermore, teachers unions such as ours carry an additional burden. Not only are teachers unions tasked with the same responsibilities of all labor unions: advancing member interests in respect to wages, benefits, and working conditions; they also are charged with protecting the promise of a quality public education for all. Historically, public education has paved the way to the middle class, it has been he vehicle for social mobility. In sum, it has had a democratizing effect in our society. Teachers unions are the only institution that  have stood in the way of so-called reformers who seek only to privatize public education and gain access to tax payer dollars. (I’ll discuss this corporate education agenda more deeply in a future post.)

We need look no further than the mission statement of the California Teachers Association to realize the role of teachers unions today.

“The California Teachers Association exists to protect and promote the well-being of its members; to improve the conditions of teaching and learning; to advance the cause of free, universal and quality public education; to ensure that the human dignity and civil rights of all children and youth are protected; and to secure a more just, equitable, and democratic society.”

So while we look to improve salary and health benefits, we also seek things like smaller class sizes, professional development teacher evaluation, use of technology, the use of resources for Special Education and English Language Learners. 

Clearly, what we do as teachers for the individual students that cross the threshold of our classroom is very important to each and every one of those students. What we do collectively as  part of our professional union is equally important to our community, our state and our nation.

Up next: Labor Union Myths

Gearing up to protect public education

As we settle into 2015, its interesting to reflect on the challenges that we faced last year. We were victorious on so many fronts: We came together to defeat Brand and his unilateral health benefits change; we won a PERB ruling that has positive implications for every CTA local union; we successfully negotiated a contract that made movement in all areas identified by members as top priorities; we reached a favorable resolution on two major arbitrations; we mounted a campaign that saw four of our five candidates elected. Its no wonder that the San Diego and Imperial Counties Labor Council has recognized the Sweetwater Education Association as Union of the Year.

Yet, these victories do not mean that all of our problems have disappeared. There are clearly issues that we must continue to deal with. The election of a new school board, and even the eventual naming of a new superintendent, will not magically make the concerns at sites go away. As President, I've had to intervene in situations where bullying administrators from CPM and HTH created truly toxic environments at their sites. Although we have seen resolution to many of the problems at these sites, we continue to deal with the practice of administrators and district officials ignoring progressive discipline and going straight to suspensions without pay. Dealing with these types of matters, along with salary, benefits, and working conditions, are a part of what unions do as their day to day responsibilities of representation; however, there is so much more we need to address.

Its not paranoia if theyre really after you

We are living in an environment where public education is undeniably under attack. Since the 1980s with the publication of A Nation at Risk, there has been a strong push to discredit the American public education system. No Child Left Behind and the high stakes testing that came with it, including the new SBAC tests, have been about composing a picture of failing schools, and laying blame squarely on teachers. Why?

According to the US Department of Education there are approximately 98,000 public schools in the United States, serving close to 50 million students. Organizations like ALEC (American Legislative Exchange Council) and their corporate allies have the agenda of dismantling public education for the simple goal of creating profit-making opportunities. In other words, If you have failing schools, we have the program that will save them, for the low, low price of…” The only thing that has stood in their way up to this point: teachers unions.

To deal with unions, the narrative of the bad teacher becomes critical. If teachers are to blame, unions are depicted as the root of the problem for protecting them.  The next step, then, is to discredit unions and take away their power. In states like Wisconsin and Michigan we have seen the virtual disappearance of union rights in order to eliminate the bargaining abilities of teachers unions. Even in Illinois, where the Chicago Teachers Union has proven to be a powerful force to contend with, the governor has recently signed a decree that effectively attempts to impose right-to-work rules. In California, we have been lucky enough to have a Democratic governor and State Assembly that has resisted this national movement, but we cant continue to rely on luck. Cases like Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association attempt to circumvent state legislatures and take issues like fair share payment out of the hands of elected representatives and put them in the hands of a very unfriendly US Supreme Court.

The success of our union will depend on our ability and willingness to engage with the larger issues before us: high stakes testing, protecting our community schools from the encroachment of charters, the erosion of labor rights, and the de-professionalization of teaching, to name just a few. We cant leave this battle up to CTA or NEA, as if somehow our state and national organizations exist apart from us. This fight is everybodys fight.

Our victories over the last 19 months have prepared us to take our unionism to the next level. While we will always focus on our local issues, our every action must be geared towards preserving the promise of public education for all; it’s critical for a democratic society. This is our fight and we need to prepare for it. I hope that you will join me, and your SEA brothers and sisters, as we champion students, teachers, our community, and public education!




Comments to Chula Vista Elementary School District on a CVLCC Charter expansion

President Tremper, Ms. Bejarano, Ms. Bunker, Mr. Reyes, Mr. Tamayo and Dr. Escobedo. Good evening.

 My name is Roberto Rodriguez, I’m the president of the Sweetwater Education Association. The union that represent Sweetwater teachers. 

Normally I would not come before this Board, frankly I usually have my hands full with my own school board. However, this evening you are considering an item that impacts teachers and students of both districts and our shared Chula Vista community.

I will refrain from making the argument that private charter schools are a drain on an already underfunded public school system. And I won’t even point to the multiple studies that show that students of charter schools actually do worse on standardized tests than their public school counterparts.

Tonight I’m going to stick to the legal issue of Prop 39. 

My guess is that at this point you’ve been told that you MUST approve this, that you have no choice and that you are mandated to do so by Prop. 39.

The pertinent section of California Ed Code is 47614, enacted by prop 39 which states:

“Each school district shall make available, to each charter school operating in the school district, facilities sufficient for the charter school to accommodate all of the charter school's in-district students in conditions reasonably equivalent to those in which the students would be accommodated if they were attending other public schools of the district.”

What you probably have not been told is that the in the case of Sequoia Union HSD v. Aurora Charter High School (20003), the California Court of Appeals, stated that this section imposes an obligation on a school district “in which a charter school provides education to students who live in that district, and who, were they not attending the charter school, would be accommodated by schools in that district.”

Because you are an elementary school district, by definition the students that are attending the secondary grades at an expanded CVLCC would not be accommodated by schools in your district. If they were not attending the charter they would be attending Sweetwater schools. 

You have absolutely NO obligation therefore to build and provide facilities to the charter due to needs that result from their expansion into the secondary grades.

I would venture to guess that the parents of Silver Wing would much rather we stop spending scarce public school funds on charters and that you spend that $3.3 million on their school and on their children. That IS your obligation.

United Taxi Drivers of San San Diego Score a Victory!

Yesterday I received a message from Richard Barrera, Secretary-Treasurer of the San Diego and Imperial Counties Labor Council. I want to share it with you for a couple of important reasons. First, at a time when unions are under attack, it's important to celebrate victories. Second, it's a great example of why it's important for unions to be involved in politics. The hard work of Labor Council to get a majority of middle class friendly members on the San Diego City Council is what created the opportunity for a victory for our union brothers and sisters in the United Taxi Workers of San Diego.

This is just another reason why I'm excited that SEA is part of the Labor Council and proud to be a member of the council's executive board.


Richard Barrera's Message . . .

Brothers and Sisters,

As taxi workers streamed out onto the Civic Concourse Monday night chanting "USA, USA!,"  we all felt a surge of pride and clarity about what it means to be an American Union Member.  The Taxi Workers, proud members of the United Taxi Workers of San Diego, had just won one of the most important policy victories for working families in San Diego history.  In summary, by an 8-1 bipartisan vote, the City Council approved a motion by Marti Emerald to lift the cap on taxi permits issued by the City, meaning that drivers who currently pay on average nearly $10,000 a year in leases to permit holders can now become owner operators.  And that means drivers now have the freedom and opportunity to support their families through their hard work.  

 The victory by UTWSD comes five years after drivers, improperly classified as independent contractors and without NLRB recognition, came together and organized a strike to protest their wages, benefits and working conditions.  Despite constant harassment, retaliation and intimidation by permit holders and dispatch companies over the last five years, and despite obstruction by public agencies, these workers stuck together, fought back against injustice, and prevailed.  It reminds and teaches all of us that a union is not formed by formal government recognition, it is formed by workers standing together to fight for justice and a brighter future for their families.  And UTWSD clarifies for all of us a path to victory for workers even in the age of Harris v. Quinn, ALEC, the Koch Brothers and the anti-worker elements of San Diego (see the Regional Chamber of Commerce, which spoke out against the taxi workers last night).  Victory comes from organizers listening to workers, developing leaders, planning a path to win and sticking to the plan no matter how hard it gets.  The UTWSD path, although creative and relevant to modern times, is the path that built not only the labor movement, but every movement in the history of our country that has pushed us closer to our American ideals.  Thank you Mikaiil, Sarah, and the members of UTWSD for making us a more perfect union.

In Solidarity,


Richard Barrera


San Diego and Imperial Counties Labor Council

See pictures from the City Council meeting...

Why Teachers Ignore Politics At Their Perill

One of the questions I hear a lot this time of year is “Why is my union involved in politics?”  That question always surprises me, especially when it comes from members. I understand the sentiment behind it. None of us went into education because we wanted to be involved in politics. We made the choice to get into education to teach our students. As teachers, we tend to believe that we can live in our own little isolated bubble that begins and ends at our classroom door. Most of us like teaching because we believe that once the bell rings, and we close our classroom door we can just teach with little or no interference; however, this is a myth. Perhaps there was some truth to it 25 years ago when I first started teaching, but no longer.

My first year of teaching I was given a World History textbook, the district’s Program Goals and Objectives and I was told, from this chapter to that chapter 1st semester, and up to the Vietnam War 2nd semester. How I navigated each of the 184 days of instruction was largely up to me. It was accepted that I was a professional who knew what I was doing and could instruct my students. And just to makes sure this was the case, the principal popped in two or three times a year. Today, we have DLTs, CCSS, PTs, EOCs, SBACs, and the never-ending walk-throughs. It’s like we need a traffic cop at the classroom door. How did it get like this? Politics.

 There is not one minute of our day that has not been decided by politics. The number of instructional minutes, the curriculum you teach, the textbook you use, the students in your classroom, the iPad you have to integrate into your instruction, the reporting of grades, the number of times your administrator visits your classroom, the instructional materials you can and can’t use, the tests you must prepare students for and the tests you have to proctor. All of this is the result of decisions made in the political arena. Politicians at the national level establish policies like Race to the Top and develop curriculum like Common Core, then state level politicians make decisions on how it will be implemented.

Yet, that’s not the end of it. Elected school board officials come in and make decisions that impact us directly in the classroom: from the tone of contract negotiations, to iPad rollouts, to using funds to buy new buildings, to open enrollment policies, to who is the principal at what site. All of these are decisions that are approved by the school board. Who sits on a school board should matter to all of us because their decisions, and their approval of the superintendent’s policies, affect each and every one of us. A year ago, when Ed Brand decided that he would unilaterally change the district’s contribution to our benefits, the school board could have stopped him. They could have said, “No, we will honor our agreement.” They didn’t. Let me give you a more recent example. Our San Ysidro brothers and sisters were out on strike last week. Their interim superintendent wanted to impose a 6.5% salary cut. Two board members refused to impose. Because there are only four sitting members on that board, the District was forced to come back to the table and settle. The superintendent was unable to impose his will. Who sits on our school board matters. It impacts our ability to teach and our students’ ability to learn.

We are three weeks away from Election Day. In Nicholas Segura, Paula Hall, Frank Tarantino, Adrian Arancibia and Arturo Solis, we have five solid public education advocates. They are invested in their communities, teacher supporters, and three of them have strong union background. Most importantly, they all care for our students. We need your help to get them elected. Imagine if 20% of SEA members decided to participate in precinct walking and phone banking; we could wind up this campaign in two weeks. Yet, we haven’t had the turn out we need for a campaign this large. There is no way that a handful of people can do all of it.

In the coming weeks I need you to step up and come to phone banking and/or precinct walking. I know I’m asking you to give up a couple of hours one evening, or a few hours on a Saturday morning. I know, it’s your family time; it’s your children’s time. Yet, I’m asking you to be proactive and help set the course for how this district will be run over the next few years. Otherwise, I’m sure that later I will be asking you to come out and picket, protest, and work to the rule. We did a great job with our defensive game last year. Now it is time for our offensive line to take charge. 

SEA President's Report for September 2014

As we head to a well-deserved fall break, I hope you’ve weathered the recent heat wave and that you will be able to recharge and energize for the rest of the first semester. I want to take the opportunity to inform you about a historic opportunity we have, and how you can help. Of course, I'm talking about the upcoming school board elections.

 After last school year, I understand the reflex of wanting to hunker down, go in to our classrooms and just teach, to not concern ourselves with the outside world. We can’t do that. 

 What’s the big deal about the school board anyway?

School boards matter because they are the ones in charge! Consider: 

  • It was our school board that hired Jesus Gandara.
  • It was our school board that allowed Gandara to lead us into fact-finding during negotiations for the first time ever.
  • It was the school board that, along with Gandara, participated in illegal activities with construction companies and vendors.
  • It was the school board that allowed Gandara, and later Brand, to begin the process of unnecessarily RIF’ing teachers.
  • It was our school board that hired Ed Brand. 
  • It was the school board that allowed Dr. Brand to violate our contract and cut our insurance last year.
  • It was the school board that allowed negotiations to reach the point of a possible strike. 
  • Its was the school board that approved the iPad rollout without questioning the viability of the plan or ensuring proper infrastructure. 
  • More importantly, it will be the newly elected school board that will hire our next superintendent. 

Clearly, school boards matter a great deal. They have the power to impact our lives, and the lives of our students and their families. 

Opportunity of a lifetime …

For the first time in my almost 30 years in this district, all five seats are up for election. It’s an opportunity to have a major impact on who sits on our school board. SEA has endorsed five solid candidates, all of them with a vested interest in the success of our district. We have parents, educators, union members, and most of all candidates who want to bring ethical behavior to our district and focus on the task of educating our students. SEA’s candidates understand that our work environment is our students’ learning environment. If you haven’t heard about our endorsed candidates, talk to reps at your sites, and visit our new website: for more info.

Yet, when opportunity presents itself, hard work comes with it. SEA is planning a full-blown campaign for our endorsed candidates; however, there are no amounts of mailers or signs that will win these elections. Studies show that in school board elections, mailers have a marginal impact and yard signs have a negligible impact. When was the last time you were convinced by a yard sign to vote for someone? Or a piece of mail that you glanced at for 6 seconds before you threw it in the trash? We do these things because it’s a quick way to get a candidate’s name out in the public eye, but what makes a major impact on voters is personal contact. 

Here is what I need you to do!

During break come to the SEA office to phone bank for our candidates. We will be phone-banking Monday through Thursday, from 4-6 pm. We would love campaign crews to sign up at this website; we can always accommodate any individuals! Additionally, we will also be walking precincts every Saturday. Bring a friend, meet at the SEA office at 8:30am, and precinct walk from 9am to noon. 

Why is it so critical to do this during break?

 We still think of elections as happening in November; however, 54% of the voters in our district are permanent mail voters. Those ballots arrive in mailboxes the first week of October. If we dont get the word out for our candidates over break, we will miss a substantial number of voters. We can’t afford to do that. Not when two former board members are running for their seats again! Not when other candidates indicated the desire to tie evaluations to student test scores or expand charter opportunities! Do you want more of the same? Please help shape the future of our District.